Columbus Ohio

445 Hutchinson Avenue, Suite 950
Columbus, OH 43235
Telephone: 614.568.1960

Our team of mortgage professionals in Columbus, Ohio can help you find the perfect home! The home of the Buckeys boasts a diverse culture and something for everyone to love. A vibrant arts and music scene, college sports, bustline downtown, and a variety of housing options make Columbus a desirable place to live.   Contact any of our mortgage loan originators or press the “Apply” button to get started today!

What Our Customers Are Saying

Hallmark Home Mortgage has been recognized as Fort Wayne’s best mortgage lender in the Fort Wayne Newspaper’s Readers Choice poll four years in a row. Our commitment to you shows in our quick closing times, and excellent communication. Our team will work hard to make sure you  are informed throughout the process to ensure a stress-free borrowing experience.

Hallmark Home Mortgage
4.8
Based on 36 reviews
powered by Google
Porshia Boyce
Porshia Boyce
16:25 04 Apr 21
Brook and he’s team are phenomenal. They truly know what is needed to get you in the position to being a homeowner.... They were so, humble to break down everything for me to understand the ins and outs. This was a journey, but the best journey well in their terms best milestone I ever met. Me and my family are enjoying our new home and I am proud to called a HOMEOWNER!!!! Thank you again for everything.read more
Desmond Elious
Desmond Elious
11:04 01 Mar 21
Unfortunately, my experience with Hallmark Home Mortgage was quite inconveniencing, TO SAY THE LEAST. I don't even feel... like writing this negative review because I'd rather not give even a single shred more of my attention/energy to this headache I've amassed trying to get through this loan process for MONTHS, but I must follow through with due diligence and give fair warning to the public that may be interested in doing business with this agency. At first things seemed to be fine and promising for me and then as soon as the process started to escalate past the front door, it just became a mess. Long story short,1. this lender apparently either lost all of my information I provided them multiple times , OR they are just so poorly organized as a business that staff somehow are incapable of conveying and communicating client information. I had to resubmit things multiple times and experienced excessive hassle and delay.2. they were terrible about communication and getting back to me with updates esp when I would reach out with specific questions. I would leave voice mails, send texts, emails, and receive no feedback at times. Some employees had full mailboxes and just couldn't be reached when needed. I would get no callbacks.3. My credit was ran TWICE without my knowledge or consent, highly damaging my Fico score.4. There's more details but like I said I'm exhausted with this lender's BS and don't even want to spend anymore focus to even type this review.5. In the end they wouldn't even give me the loan that I was already approved and had met all conditions for. The whole process felt like I was fighting a tedious uphill battle, tooth and nail against these people the whole time over what should have been a simple loan deal. It was as if they never actually wanted me to succeed.I WILL NOT be doing business with them again or recommending anyone to this agency.read more
Gregg Butkewicz
Gregg Butkewicz
13:38 19 Feb 21
I had my original loan and two refis done thru Hallmark with Evonne Davies. I returned after the first time because of... the ease with which Evonne ran the process. I was clearly instructed what documents I would need to bring, money needed for closing and where I stood during the process. It was easy. If rates drop another point, I will be coming back. Highly recommend.read more
Souhaibou Sy
Souhaibou Sy
10:43 13 Feb 21
Sheila Chamber helped to do my home refinance.She did an excellent job. Once I submitted all the paperwork she... requested me, she was on it.She took the time to explain me everything. Whenever I had questions during the process, she make sure to help me to get to understand every detail.Not only she was always available, but she make sure to answer my phone calls within the 24 hours period.I am glad all went well in a short amount of time.She did an amazing job. I definitely recommend her.I am looking forward to work with her in the futureCause I was very satisfied of her Job.read more
Kaitlyn Nangle
Kaitlyn Nangle
15:04 19 Jan 21
Evonne's dedication to helping my husband and I get the home we dreamed of will not be forgotten. During our loan... process, she was there every step, even while on vacation and late in the evening, to make sure we were able get all our questions answered and our loan approved! Thank you for everything!read more
Candice Brothers
Candice Brothers
22:59 03 Dec 20
We definitely enjoyed working with Brook and the advice he gave us while buying our first home. We will definitely keep... him in mind to refer to friends and if we decide to sell our home and move elsewhere.read more
A Google User
A Google User
02:19 06 Oct 20
Excellent organization. Shelia was extremely responsive and knowledgeable about all options available as we purchased... our home. Great experience, I would recommend Shelia to anyone ready to purchase a home!read more
Brenda Brown
Brenda Brown
16:39 04 Oct 20
Shelia, was professional, extremely knowledgeable, and personable. She was always easy to reach and willing to answer... allmy questions. I felt she held my hand during this process and walked me through everything. She is a great credit to her company.read more
Lyndsey Deroads
Lyndsey Deroads
09:18 24 Aug 20
Evonne and her team were great to work with. They made refinancing our home so quick and simple. I would highly... recommend!read more
Juliana
Juliana
15:42 18 Aug 20
I went through the process with Brook Gibbs! He was amazing!! This process was all new to me as I am a first time home... buyer however, he made sure everything ran smooth! Thank you Brook for your patience and attentiveness!!read more
Larry Conner
Larry Conner
13:03 12 Aug 20
Awesome company and experience. Great customer service. Fast response. The app is awesome and the ability to upload... required documents made the process more efficient and smooth! Highly Recommend Jeff and his team at Hallmark Mortgage!read more
William Spruill
William Spruill
13:21 21 Jul 20
This is my second go around with Sheila Chambers. The first time around we chose a bank and Sheila's company ultimately... having to choose one to finish. The bank dropped us two weeks before closing. Sheila picked up the pieces and had it done in 11 days. So there was no question who would handle my refinance. I would pick her and her company over anything hands down you will not be dissatisfied. They go above and beyond your expectations and are very knowledgeable.read more
Brittney Slaughter
Brittney Slaughter
00:55 08 Jul 20
Amazing service with Hallmark! Shelia was extremely informative and great to work with! Her willingness to work around... the clock to answer any and all questions was exceptional. She was with me every step of the way. It truly shows when people enjoy their career! I highly recommend Shelia for your next venture!read more
dylan baltzer
dylan baltzer
11:07 19 May 20
Sheila chambers was an amazing person to deal with always there to help and always super nice. She did whatever she... could to make the process as easy and fast. She made sure to reach out in multiple forms whenever the next step was needed. I would not rather have felt with anyone else thank you for all of your help.read more
Julia O
Julia O
22:58 04 Apr 20
As a first time home buyer I highly recommend Hallmark Mortgage. Our representative, Brook Gibbs, was available to us... via email, phone call and, most conveniently, text. He explained the process thoroughly and clearly and answered every question we had. You can really tell he loves his job and helping people! He made what could be a very stressful process very smooth and comfortable for us. I knew he was going to guide us to success. Thankfully we found our perfect house and closed very quickly and we are so grateful to have had Brook and Hallmark mortgage helping us the whole way.read more
Claire
Claire
21:00 10 Dec 19
My experience with Evonne was great! She was very responsive and helpful throughout the entire process. This was my... first home purchase and I couldn’t be happier with the service I received. Thank you Evonne!read more
David Hayes
David Hayes
09:53 01 Dec 19
Amazing service went threw the process Shelia Chambers was top notch. Great communication, never had a call or text go... unanswered right away 24/7. Just a pleasant experience. Thank you all.read more
Sawan Patel
Sawan Patel
14:00 06 Oct 19
One word: EXCELLENT!!!! We worked with Shelia before during our purchase of the first house. Shelia takes genuine... interest and makes sure that all paperwork to be in-order all the time!! We would love to work with Shelia!!! Best in the business.read more
Krista Killian
Krista Killian
22:45 29 Sep 19
Great mortgage company and Jeff was great with getting back to you and making things work. I recommend this company and... Jeff.read more
Martie Kirchoff
Martie Kirchoff
12:56 03 Aug 19
When I initially applied for my home loan the end of June, I wasn’t sure about the home buying process since I haven’t... bought a home in many years. I wasn’t even sure I qualified for a mortgage. Jeff Dray provided me with advice on what to do to ensure that I qualified. I followed his advice and soon after that Jeff was confident that we could be homeowners and close by the middle of August. I am elated to say... we closed July 31st!!! Jeff was such an asset to us in this process and Carrie was wonderful to help get it all buttoned up in the end. Thank You! We will be recommending Hallmark to our friends!!read more
Next Reviews

Ready to Get Started?

One of our Columbus team members can help answer your mortgage questions and find the right solution for you.

Mortgage Resources

Looking for answers about the mortgage process? We're here to help.

Calculate Your Payment

Our easy to use mortgage calculator can help you determine a payment that is right for you.